定语从句中表地点的from where 与from which 有什么区别?

2024-12-14 20:44:32
推荐回答(4个)
回答1:

都填which,在定语从句中,from which=where,都在从句中担任地点状语的成分。
上面两个句子都是非限制性定语从句,先行词分别是the top of the mountain和the window,在从句中作地点状语,又因为是非限制性定语从句,所以填from which。
上面的句子如果改成限制性定语从句也是对的:
1.He climbed up to the top of the mountain where he could see clearly.
2.He appeared out of the window where the whole city came into view.

回答2:

题目好像不是很完整,see sb./sth.所以第一句缺宾语,如果加上一个宾语,句子完整的话,就该选择from where,这里的where指代的是 from on the top of the mountain, 而on the top of the mountain 用where 替代。
第二题也是同理,from where替代的是from the out of window, 所以都选择where的,
个人想法,答案仅供参考。。。

回答3:

定语从句中,当先行词指物时,只有介词+which,没有from where的用法,当指地点时介词+which= where,当不能既用介词又用关系副词where。

1.He climbed up to the top of the mountain, from _which___ (which/ where) he could see clearly.

因为此句中的先行词是the top of the mountain,指物,且放在介词from之后,所以用which,from which = where。

2.He appeared out of the window, from _which______ (where/which)the whole city came into view.

先行词rhe window。 理由同第一题。

回答4:

both are which
没有from where 的形式